Deck vs screened porch vs sunroom: which should you build?

All three give you more room to live outside the main house. They work very differently, and the right one depends on how you want to use it and how much upkeep you will accept.

Call (336) 654-1130Serving Burlington and nearby Alamance County townsEstimates scheduled by phone

Start with how you will use it

The best way to choose among these three is to picture a normal day. Do you want to grill and eat outdoors on warm evenings? Sit with coffee in the morning with no mosquitoes? Have a bright room you can enjoy on a gray winter afternoon? Each answer points to a different structure.

A deck is an open platform. It is made for grills, sunbathing, parties and play. A screened porch is a roofed space with screens instead of walls, so you get breezes and no bugs. A sunroom is an enclosed room with lots of glass, which can be used in more seasons. They overlap, but each has a personality, and each has costs that are not obvious at first.

The deck

A deck is the simplest and most flexible of the three. It can be small or large, low to the ground or raised, plain or multilevel. Because it has no roof or walls, it costs the least per square foot and goes up the fastest. It is the right choice if you want space for grilling, dining and entertaining in good weather and you do not mind that it is exposed to sun, rain and insects.

The tradeoff is that a deck is only useful when the weather cooperates. Summer afternoons can be brutal in direct sun, and evening mosquitoes can drive you inside. A deck also needs the most regular maintenance of the three, because the surface boards take the full force of weather. See our page on decks and porches for more.

The screened porch

A screened porch adds a roof and screened walls to the idea of a deck. The roof gives shade and keeps rain off furniture. The screens keep out mosquitoes, gnats and wasps, and also leaves and pollen. In this part of North Carolina, where summer evenings are warm and humid and insects are plentiful, a screened porch is often the most-used outdoor room in the house.

It costs more than a deck because of the roof and framing, and it is usually built with permits. It is also a lower-maintenance space, since the roof protects the floor. It works well with a ceiling fan, which makes humid evenings comfortable. Read about construction details in our page on screened porch construction.

The sunroom

A sunroom goes further. Its walls are mostly glass, and it can be insulated and conditioned to make it a true room. A three-season sunroom is comfortable in spring and fall. A four-season sunroom with proper insulation, glass and heating and cooling can be used all year.

A sunroom is the most expensive of the three, and the most like an addition. It needs a real foundation, structure, roof and mechanical systems, and often a permit and engineering. It is a good choice when you want a bright, protected room year-round. It also needs thoughtful design to avoid overheating in summer. See sunroom additions for details.

Side-by-side thinking

  • Season of use: deck in good weather, screened porch most of spring through fall, sunroom much or all of the year.
  • Bug protection: none on a deck, full on a screened porch and sunroom.
  • Weather protection: none on a deck, partial on a screened porch, full in a sunroom.
  • Upkeep: deck highest, screened porch moderate, sunroom lowest outside but with glass to clean.
  • Cost: deck lowest, screened porch in the middle, sunroom highest.
  • Permits and complexity: deck simplest, sunroom most involved.

Questions that settle it

  1. Will you use the space in summer evenings, when bugs are worst?
  2. Do you want it in winter too?
  3. How much shade does the area get, and which way does it face?
  4. How much do you want to spend now, and how much on upkeep later?
  5. Do you need a space for grilling, with smoke ventilation?
  6. Do you want to add heating and cooling?
  7. Will the new space attach to the kitchen or the living room, and does that change its size?

Combining them

Many homeowners do not have to choose one. A screened porch can open onto a deck, giving you a roofed, bug-free sitting area and an open grilling and sunning area side by side. A deck can be designed so a roof and screens can be added later. A screened porch can later be converted to a sunroom, if it is built with that in mind. Planning ahead gives you flexibility.

If you already have a deck that is in decent shape, adding a roof and screens may be the most economical way to get a screened porch. We check the existing structure first. If the framing and footings are sound, it can be done. If not, rebuilding may make more sense. Read about deck remodeling.

The climate here

Piedmont summers are hot and humid. Thunderstorms are frequent. Pollen season in spring covers everything in yellow. Winters are mild compared with the north but have cold snaps. That climate shapes the choice. A deck in full sun can be too hot to walk on barefoot at midday. A screened porch with a fan gives comfort when the air is warm and still. A sunroom without proper glass and cooling can be unbearable in July.

Choose materials with the climate in mind. Rot-resistant wood, composite decking, corrosion-resistant fasteners and good flashing matter a lot here.

Next step

If you are leaning toward one, call (336) 654-1130. We will visit the site, look at sun and layout and give you honest advice. We can also look at the house to see whether an existing deck or porch can be reused. See also porch remodeling for existing porches that need new life.

A note on materials

Whatever you choose, the materials matter. Pressure-treated lumber, composite boards, vinyl railings and aluminum framing all behave differently in the heat and humidity of the Piedmont. Ask what each costs to maintain over ten years, not just at purchase.

Questions we hear on the phone

Short answers to what callers ask most. Call if yours is not here.

Which is cheapest?

A deck, usually, followed by a screened porch and then a sunroom.

Can I add screens to my deck later?

If it has a roof and a sound structure, often yes.

Is a sunroom a true addition?

A four-season sunroom is, and is treated like one for permits.

Which needs the least maintenance?

A sunroom or a screened porch, depending on materials.

Tell us about your project.

Call and we will schedule your estimate.

Call (336) 654-1130
Call (336) 654-1130